Showing posts with label malaysia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label malaysia. Show all posts

Thursday, February 07, 2013

Comparative defamation law and practice - focus on Southeast Asia

Below are the opening paragraphs of a paper I gave to a conference in Hong Kong, in 2007, on comparative defamation law and practice - focusing on Southeast Asia. The full text can be downloaded by clicking here.



International and Southeast Asian law and practice on defamation

Hong Kong, 2007

Defamation is among the most litigated issues in media law. This is true domestically as well as internationally.[1] In South-east Asia, as elsewhere in the world, politicians and powerful business people often abuse the defamation laws in an attempt to silence their opponents and critics. In most South-east Asian countries, defamation can be prosecuted under both the criminal and the civil law. Both raise their own sets of specific issues, although civil liability is internationally thought to be the better solution.

This paper will outline international human rights law and best practice on defamation, and compare and contrast that with national practice.[2]

At the international level, a rich body of defamation case law has been established by international human rights courts. The European Court of Human Rights has been the most active. In the 21 years since that Court delivered its first judgment in a defamation case,[3] it has built up a considerable body of jurisprudence. Over the last decade or so, other international courts, including the United Nations Human Rights Committee and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, have also begun to hear defamation cases and are building up a jurisprudence of their own. Given the similarity of the freedom of expression provisions in each of the treaties whose implementation these bodies oversee, the references they make to each other’s jurisprudence, and the fact that the bodies tend to follow each other in the substance of their decisions, it is appropriate to view their jurisprudence as a united body of law. This paper will review that body of law, under the following general headings:[4]

·         Freedom of expression protects offensive speech
·         The status of public figures and the importance of debate on matters of public interest
·         The distinction between opinion and fact
·         The defence of truth
·         The defence of ‘reasonable publication’
·         Penalties

We will also briefly consider procedural matters, including the question whether legal aid should be available to impecunious defendants and on the protection of journalists’ sources.

Finally, this paper touches on the question whether criminal defamation laws as such are compatible with the right to freedom of expression. International bodies such as the UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Opinion and Expression have long advised that criminal defamation laws are incompatible with the right to freedom of expression, and an important decision moving in this direction has been rendered by the Indonesian Constitutional Court. The implications of this judgment are important, not only in Indonesia but in the region.

I.     Freedom of Expression Protects Offensive Speech

Sources of international law on freedom of expression applicable in South-east Asia

The right to freedom of expression is guaranteed through various international treaties and declarations. The following paragraphs briefly review those instruments that are of specific relevance to the South-east Asian States targeted in the current training session.

Article 19 of the Universal Declaration on Human Rights (UDHR),[5] a United Nations General Assembly resolution, guarantees the right to freedom of expression in the following terms:

Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes the right to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart informa­tion and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.

The UDHR is not directly binding on States but parts of it, including Article 19, have arguably acquired legal force as customary international law.[6] It has also been cited in various ASEAN documents,[7] and the majority of South-east Asian States took part in the 1993 Vienna World Conference on Human Rights that reaffirmed its full commitment to the UDHR.[8]




[1]               The notable exception is Singapore, where between 2004 and 2006, less than 10 cases were officially reported. It seems, however, that many cases are settled out of court, possibly due to the harsh nature of the law and the limited chances of success of most media defendants.
[2]               Examples of national practice have been taken from the country reports submitted by national facilitators and resource material developers appointed for this training session. The author of this paper would like to express his thanks to these coordinators for sharing their work. 
[3]               Lingens v. Austria, 8 July 1986, Application No. 9815/82.
[4]               Where appropriate, we will also refer to the jurisprudence of leading national courts of final appeal.
[5]              UN General Assembly Resolution 217A(III), adopted 10 December 1948.
[6]               See, for example, Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company Limited Case (Belgium v. Spain) (Second Phase), ICJ Rep. 1970 3 (International Court of Justice); Namibia Opinion, ICJ Rep. 1971 16, Separate Opinion, Judge Ammoun (International Court of Justice); Filartiga v. Pena-Irala, 630 F. 2d 876 (1980) (US Circuit Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit). Generally, see M.S.McDougal, H.D.Lasswell, L.C.Chen, Human Rights and World Public Order, Yale University Press (1980), pp. 273-74, 325-27.
[7]               See, for example, the Ha Noi Plan of Action, adopted at the 6th ASEAN Summit 15-16 December 1998, Hanoi, Vietnam. Malaysia is a founding Member Country of ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations).
[8]               Report of the World Conference on Human Rights, UN Doc. No. A/CONF.157/24 (Part I), 13 October 1993. 

Friday, January 25, 2013

Freedom of Expression in South-East Asia - Trends and Challenges in Media Law

Below are the opening paragraphs and link to the full text of a conference paper I delivered in Hong Kong, in 2007:


"The aim of the current three day training course organised by Hong Kong University is therefore to strengthen media freedom in South-East Asia by building and strengthening national and regional capacity for media defence litigation, which has been identified as a key means to promote a free media in many countries. Lawyers from each of the six countries concerned will be brought together to discuss international and regional law and practice on freedom of expression, and to identify ways of bringing progressive international legal arguments in a domestic setting.

This paper seeks to provide an overview of the main legal trends and challenges to freedom of expression in the six countries surveyed. It also discusses the status in the region of international human rights law and the options for lawyers wishing to bring international and comparative law arguments in a domestic setting, and concludes with some suggestions as to the way forward.

I.     Practice across the region

Practice in the region shows that defamation is the chief challenge to freedom of expression. However, numerous other laws are also in active use to restrict media freedom beyond the level that is accepted under international human rights law. The following paragraphs provide a bird's eye view of freedom of expression law and practice in the region.

For full text click here. 

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Raja Petra update

Raja Petra, a Malaysian on-line magazine editor, has been charged with sedition as well as under the Internal Security Act for a piece that he wrote back in April alleging the involvement of the deputy prime minister in a murder case. He is currently detained under the ISA.A habeas corpus application asking for his release will be decided on November 7, but even if he is freed then his sedition trial is set to continue November 10. In a piece that he wrote in another online publication, Access Malaysia, he describes this as the government taking out a double insurance policy to make sure he is kept behind lock and key.

A group of media defense lawyers from the region are cooperating in his defence. Malik Imtiaz is acting for Raja Petra (see here for his blog report on the hearing of 22nd October). The IBA sent observers to his habeas corpus hearing - George Hwang, from Singapore, was one of them. H.R. Dipendra, another Malaysian lawyer, was instructed by the Media Legal Defence Initiative (the new organisation set up to support media defence litigation) and SEAPA to also attend as 'watching brief' counsel and submitted a statement international human rights standards on administrative detention.

Thursday, September 25, 2008

Malaysian bloggers: one freed, one behind bars for two years

The Herald Tribune reports that Syed Azidi Syed Aziz, who writes Kickdefella, has been freed from detention. He had been arrested and investigated for sedition after publishing a picture of the Malaysian flag upside down as a form of protest.

Meanwhile....

Raja Petra has been arrested and is facing two years detention under the Internal Security Act - he's a national security risk, apparently. The man is clearly not and his detention is clearly politically motivated. A habeas corpus petition for his release will be filed soon.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Sedition: Gambian journalist convicted, Malaysian cases continue

Sedition laws continue to be abused around the world to suppress critical voices. In the Gambia, it was today reported that a journalist was convicted of sedition and given a choice between a USD12K fine or four years imprisonment with hard labour. Over on the other side of the globe, in Malaysia, the rich and powerful continue to abuse sedition laws to suppress critical (and sometimes not only very harshly critical, but also prima facie defamatory) voices. The latest to join the current fray is Datuk Muhammad Shafee Abdullah, a successful lawyer, who has lodged proceedings against Malaysia Today editor Reja Patra (though he'll have to join the queue as Petra has many charges pending against him).

My problem with that: sedition laws are skewed in favour of the plaintiff and they allow for very harsh sanctions, as the Gambian case demonstrates. They are a hangover from the colonial era, when they were used to keep the locals down, and I believe they should be fought hard: the Gambian case should be brought before the ECOWAS court, and a constitutional challenge should be brought in Malaysia.

Thursday, August 07, 2008

Another Malaysia blogger has been arrested for sedition

This is becoming a bit of an issue in Malaysia - another blogger has been arrested on charges of sedition following criticial blog reports.

From the Star:

KUALA LUMPUR: Blogger Bakaq, also known as "Penarik Beca," has been arrested by Federal Commercial Crimes Investigation Department under the Sedition Act.

He was detained after four policemen in plain clothes raided his home at Taman Greenwood in Gombak at 11pm Wednesday.

It is learnt that police also seized a laptop and a handphone belonging to the blogger.

Bakaq, whose real name is Abdul Rashid Abu Bakar, is believed to have blogged recently about "hidden agenda" behind the muzakarah (dialogues) between PAS and Umno.

At 2pm Thursday, family and friends of Bakaq gathered at the federal commercial crimes headquarters in Bukit Perdana to show their support for him.

His lawyer Hanipa Maidin, who is also PAS' legal adviser, confirmed that Bakaq’s arrest was under the Sedition Act.

Monday, May 12, 2008

more Malaysia sedition charges

It is as if a memo has been circulated among Malaysia's politicians and prosecutors reminding them of the attractiveness of Malaysia's sedition laws. In addition to last week's blogger case, the Southeast Asian Press Alliance has now reported that two other sedition charges have been filed.

The first two cases were lodged on the same day. On 6 May 2008, a well-known online critic, Raja Petra Kamaruddin, and a commentator on his website, Syed Akbar Ali, were charged under the 1948 Sedition Act in the Sessions Court in the state of Selangor and the capital of Kuala Lumpur, respectively. Raja Petra and Syed Akbar are both denying the charge, and while Syed Akbar was released the same day on a bail of RM3,000 (approx. US$939), Raja Petra initially refused to post bail on a matter of principle needed four days for his wife to persuade him to change his mind. Raja Petra, 58, who runs the popular Malaysia Today website (http://www.malaysia-today.net), was charged over his 25 April article, "Let's send the Altantuya murderers to hell", which implicated Deputy Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak and his wife in the murder of a Mongolian national. Syed Akbar, 48 was charged over his 5 June 2007 online response to another article by Raja Petra, "Malaysia’s organised crime syndicate: All roads lead to Putrajaya". His trial will begin on 6 June 2008.

The third case was lodged on May 9, Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi reportedly ordered a ruling party official to lodge a separate sedition complaint against Karpal Singh, a top politician with a rival party, for questioning the jurisdiction of sultans. In this case, six members of the dominant ruling party, United Malays National Organisation, and a coalition of Malay non-governmental organisations filed two police reports against Karpal for making allegedly seditious remarks against one of the monarchs who historically rule nine out of 14 states of the constitutional monarchy in Malaysia. A 5 May report in the "Star" English daily quoted the chairperson of the Democratic Action Party as saying: "Sultan Azlan Shah did not have any say, as the Ruler of Perak, in the decision made by the state government and, by law, the palace cannot order the state government to reinstate Jamry [Sury as the state's Islamic Department director]." Jamry had been transferred to another department for refusing to cooperate with the new ruling state government in Perak, which was formed by the federal-level opposition coalition, People's Pact. The monarchy, a Malay sultanate, is one of the sensitive topics in multi-ethnic Malaysia, which is dominated by the ethnic Malays, followed by the Chinese, Indians and indigenous groups.

This could be a good opportunity to challenge the constitutionality of the charges, particularly if, as I hope, the Ugandan Supreme Court rules that the virtually identical Ugandan sedition law is unconstitutional. That might just give it the push it needs - earlier attempts having been unsuccessful. Watch this space for further developments.

Wednesday, May 07, 2008

Malaysian jailed pending hearing on charges of sedition

Reuters has reported that "a Malaysian man opted to go to jail on Tuesday instead of paying bail after he was accused of sedition for implying the country's deputy premier had a hand in the murder of a Mongolian woman, his lawyer said."

It's a convoluted story and the allegations are hard to establish, but not something anyone should be imprisoned for. Yet another example of why these kinds of laws need to be repealed - they were brought in by colonial repressors and are used now as they were then - to silence oppositional voices.