Thursday, May 14, 2009

Free speech vs. the jury trial system

There's an interesting case brewing here - it involves a jury foreman who spoke out to the media to voice his concern over the safety of a manslaughter verdict against a child carer who allegedly shook a child so violently it died. The conviction apparently relied entirely on circumstantial evidence and testimony of expert witnesses, and is itself currently being appealed.

See here for full text of the judgment.

Friday, May 08, 2009

Newspaper readers have Article 19 right to receive information

A new decision by the UN Human Rights Committee finds that every reader of a newspaper has an Article 19 right to "receive" the newspaper and material published by it. The case was brought by a newspaper editor whose paper was closed down, together with one of its readers. The Committee held:

"[T]he Committee is of the opinion that the application of the procedure of registration and re-registration of “Oina” did not allow Mr. Mavlonov, as the editor, and Mr. Sa’di, as a reader, to practice their freedom of expression, as defined in article 19, paragraph 2. The Committee notes that the State party has not made any attempt to address the authors’ specific claims, including Mr. Mavlonov’s reference to the decision of the Commission which suggests that the content of the “Oina” is the reason for the denial of the re-registration (see paragraph 2.6 above). Nor has it advanced arguments as to the compatibility of the requirements, which are de facto restrictions on the right to freedom of expression, which are applicable to the authors’ case, with any of the criteria listed in article 19, paragraph 3, of the Covenant. The Committee therefore finds that the right to freedom of expression under article 19 of the Covenant, respectively, Mr. Mavlonov’s ability to publish “Oina” and to impart information, and Mr. Sa’di’s right to receive information and ideas in print, has been violated. The Committee notes that the public has a right to receive information as a corollary of the specific function of a journalist and/or editor to impart information. It considers that Mr. Sa’di’s right to receive information as an “Oina” reader was violated by its non-registration."

The Committee also finds an Article 27 (right to culture) violation, given that the newspaper was a Tajik language one.

There is a strong dissent by Sir Nigel Rodley and Rafael Rivas Posada who disagree that readers have a self-standing Article 19 right to receive information:

"We find the Committee’s literalist reading of the right to receiving information and ideas is unconvincing. The Committee’s position would require it to treat every potential recipient of any information or ideas that have been improperly suffered under article 19 as a victim in the same way as the person having been prevented from expressing or imparting the information or ideas. Thus, it could find itself dealing with communication from every reader or viewer or listener of a medium of mass communication that has been improperly closed down or whose content has been improperly suppressed. This is not a ‘floodgates’ argument. Rather it is evident that its literalist approach may simply not be the most plausible interpretation of article 19(2). For us, this aspect of Mr. Sa’di’s complaint smacks of actio popularis."

While the Committee's reasoning could have been more elaborate, I do disagree with Rodley and Rivas - for reasons that will become obvious when you read the case.

See Mavlonov and Sa'adi v. Uzbekistan.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

Why blasphemy laws are unnecessary

During debates in the UK House of Lords, the magnificently-named Ear of Onslow had the ultimate answer to those who wish to (re)introduce/retain (as the case may be) blasphemy laws:

“[I]t has always struck me that if Jesus Christ exists, and if Jesus Christ in his Godlike form was capable of creating the universe, then he could quite easily hack the bit of left-wing obscurantism and b-mindedness that writes things such as “Jerry Springer: The Opera”. If he does not exist, nothing will happen; if he does exist, it is up to him to get hold of the chap who wrote it and make sure that he does time in the diabolical house of correction. The offence is unnecessary.”

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200708/ldhansrd/text/80305-0006.htm, column 1123

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Shut the f*** up!

No more swearing on live TV - in the States at least - the US Supreme Court has upheld the FCC's so-called 'fleeting expletives' policy. See FCC v. Fox Networks (the case followed Bono swearing at the Golden Globe awards).

Wiki-publisher on the attack against copyright 'harassment'

The Electronic Frontier Foundation is supporting a federal action in California which seeks to enjoin Apple from harassing the publisher of a wiki by threatening them with copyright violations. Interesting case, court papers are on the eff website. It's one to follow - the first one I know of where someone is actually on the legal attack against the copyright gang.

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Privacy and defamation at the ECHR - two new cases

The European Court of Human Rights has issued two new decisions on privacy and defamation: Karako v. Hungary and Egeland and Hanseid v. Norway. Karako is an Article 8 defamation case, in which the Court holds no violation for strident comments made regarding a politician during election times. The Court's reasoning is interesting as it attempts to answer some questions on the extent to which Article 8 protects reputation:

"23. For the Court, personal integrity rights falling within the ambit of Article 8 are unrelated to the external evaluation of the individual, whereas in matters of reputation, that evaluation is decisive: one may lose the esteem of society – perhaps rightly so – but not one's integrity, which remains inalienable. In the Court's case-law, reputation has only been deemed to be an independent right sporadically (see Petrina v. Romania, no. 78060/01, 14 October 2008, and Armonienė v. Lithuania, no. 36919/02, 25 November 2008) and mostly when the factual allegations were of such a seriously offensive nature that their publication had an inevitable direct effect on the applicant's private life. However, in the instant case, the applicant has not shown that the publication in question, allegedly affecting his reputation, constituted such a serious interference with his private life as to undermine his personal integrity. The Court therefore concludes that it was the applicant's reputation alone which was at stake in the context of an expression made to his alleged detriment."

This is where the reasoning ends - unfortunately. While to me it would follow that the case should be inadmissible since Article 8 is not affected (the alleged interference did not actually impinge on the private sphere), the Court goes on to apply article 10 reasoning and finds no violation of Article 8. The Court does seem to be taking time here to reflect and the decision puts an interesting gloss on Petrina and Pfeiffer. There's a partly concurring opinion by judge Jociene who favours a much bolder appraoch in favour of reputation as an article 8 right. It's a Second Section decision.

The first Section, meanwhile, continues on the pro-privacy path in Egeland and Hanseid v. Norway, a case concerning the taking of photographs of accused outside the court. Rozakis states in his concurring opinion (which otherwise is concerned with the margin of appreciation): "in matters of clashes between freedom of expression (and more specifically the taking of photographs in a public place) and the right to private life, the Court has already developed jurisprudence to the effect that the balance should be tipped in favour of private life".

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Access to Information: New Article 10 Decision

The Court has today notified its judgment in Társaság a Szabadságjogokért v. Hungary, a case which concerned an access to information request filed by the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union to the Hungarian Constitutional Court and rejected by that court on data protection grounds.

In an interesting if somewhat enigmatic judgment, the Court found a violation of Article 10:

"The law cannot allow arbitrary restrictions which may become a form of indirect censorship should the authorities create obstacles to the gathering of information. For example, the latter activity is an essential preparatory step in journalism and is an inherent, protected part of press freedom. The function of the press includes the creation of forums for public debate. However, the realisation of this function is not limited to the media or professional journalists. In the present case, the preparation of the forum of public debate was conducted by a non-governmental organisation. The purpose of the applicant's activities can therefore be said to have been an essential element of informed public debate. The Court has repeatedly recognised civil society's important contribution to the discussion of public affairs. The applicant is an association involved in human rights litigation with various objectives, including the protection of freedom of information. It may therefore be characterised, like the press, as a social “watchdog”. In these circumstances, the Court is satisfied that its activities warrant similar Convention protection to that afforded to the press.

The subject matter of the instant dispute was the constitutionality of criminal legislation concerning drug-related offences. In the Court's view, the submission of an application for an a posteriori abstract review of this legislation, especially by a Member of Parliament, undoubtedly constituted a matter of public interest. Consequently, the Court finds that the applicant was involved in the legitimate gathering of information on a matter of public importance. It observes that the authorities interfered in the preparatory stage of this process by creating an administrative obstacle. The Constitutional Court's monopoly of information thus amounted to a form of censorship. Furthermore, given that the applicant's intention was to impart to the public the information gathered from the constitutional complaint in question, and thereby to contribute to the public debate concerning legislation on drug-related offences, its right to impart information was clearly impaired.

...

The Court recalls at the outset that “Article 10 does not ... confer on the individual a right of access to a register containing information on his personal position, nor does it embody an obligation on the Government to impart such information to the individual” and that “it is difficult to derive from the Convention a general right of access to administrative data and documents”. Nevertheless, the Court has recently advanced towards a broader interpretation of the notion of “freedom to receive information” and thereby towards the recognition of a right of access to information.

...

In any event, the Court notes that “the right to freedom to receive information basically prohibits a Government from restricting a person from receiving information that others wish or may be willing to impart to him”. It considers that the present case essentially concerns an interference – by virtue of the censorial power of an information monopoly – with the exercise of the functions of a social watchdog, like the press, rather than a denial of a general right of access to official documents. In this connection, a comparison can be drawn with the Court's previous concerns that preliminary obstacles created by the authorities in the way of press functions call for the most careful scrutiny. Moreover, the State's obligations in matters of freedom of the press include the elimination of barriers to the exercise of press functions where, in issues of public interest, such barriers exist solely because of an information monopoly held by the authorities. The Court notes at this juncture that the information sought by the applicant in the present case was ready and available and did not require the collection of any data by the Government. Therefore, the Court considers that the State had an obligation not to impede the flow of information sought by the applicant.

...

The Court observes that the applicant had requested information about the constitutional complaint eventually without the personal data of its author. Moreover, the Court finds it quite implausible that any reference to the private life of the MP, hence to a protected private sphere, could be discerned from his constitutional complaint. It is true that he had informed the press that he had lodged the complaint, and therefore his opinion on this public matter could, in principle, be identified with his person. However, the Court considers that it would be fatal for freedom of expression in the sphere of politics if public figures could censor the press and public debate in the name of their personality rights, alleging that their opinions on public matters are related to their person and therefore constitute private data which cannot be disclosed without consent. These considerations cannot justify, in the Court's view, the interference of which complaint is made in the present case.

The Court considers that obstacles created in order to hinder access to information of public interest may discourage those working in the media or related fields from pursuing such matters. As a result, they may no longer be able to play their vital role as “public watchdogs” and their ability to provide accurate and reliable information may be adversely affected.

The foregoing considerations lead the Court to conclude that the interference with the applicant's freedom of expression in the present case cannot be regarded as having been necessary in a democratic society. It follows that there has been a violation of Article 10 of the Convention."

Thursday, April 09, 2009

An ancient obstacle to free speech

from the Guardian's Comment is Free:

In 1848, the Duke of Brunswick sent his agent to buy an 18-year-old copy of the Weekly Dispatch from the publishers' office. It had come to his attention that an article in the 1830 volume of that magazine was defamatory of him, and he wished to do something about it. Despite the fact that the statute of limitations back then was set at six years and the duke was able to prove only that two copies were still in circulation – the one his agent had bought and another at the British Library – the court allowed the action to go ahead and eventually awarded him £500, a tidy sum in those days.

In an ideal world, only legal historians would be familiar with this ancient tale.

Unfortunately, in the non-ideal world that we inhabit, journalists and media lawyers alike are familiar with the case; it provides the foundation of the "multiple publication rule" which, as applied today, means that every time someone accesses a page on the internet it is deemed to be "published" afresh. The result: the statute of limitations never runs out, and actions for libel can potentially be launched in perpetuity.

This is highly problematic for anyone who publishes online. Most articles, once published on the internet, are archived online, usually with their own URLs. They can show up in search results and remain accessible to one and all.

Imagine, then, the scenario of an internet user engaging in a spot of vanity-Googling and discovering, somewhere in the search results, an article written about him several years ago and published in the online edition of a newspaper. It alleges – let's say – some form of misconduct in public office. The journalist who wrote the piece has since moved on and the editor may not have access to the journalist's notes or other material relevant to the story. Our random internet user sues for libel; how is the newspaper supposed to defend a case like that? Key witnesses may have disappeared and defences such as qualified privilege may have expired with the passage of time. Surely such a case ought to be thrown out; yet the law would allow it.

Many other countries spotted some time ago that the multiple publication rule produces absurd results. The New York appeals court ruled as early as 1948 that it had "its origin in an era which long antedated the modern process of mass publication and nationwide distribution of printed information" and that it "gave scant heed to the public policy which underlies statutes of limitation, to outlaw stale claims". Instead, the court held, there should be a single publication rule, declaring that the statute of limitations begins at the point of publication of an edition (while allowing that republication or publication of a paperback edition may reset the clock); not whenever a new sale is made. This "single publication" rule has since been held to apply to internet publications as well and sets the standard for balancing the interests of protecting reputation on the one hand, and the free flow of information and ideas on the other.

The European Court of Human Rights was invited in a recent case involving The Times to confirm that the UK's multiple publication rule violated the right to freedom of expression. While it declined to provide that ruling, the European court did acknowledge that "libel proceedings brought against a newspaper after a significant lapse of time may well, in the absence of exceptional circumstances, give rise to a disproportionate interference with press freedom".

The multiple publication rule is one of several factors that render UK libel law so plaintiff-friendly and attracts such a number of foreign litigants. It poses real and serious problems for UK publishers – and not just the big national publications, but also small regional and independent publishers – and is badly in need of reform. Last December, the government promised a consultation "as soon as possible in the new year". This promised consultation is yet to materialise. It is not clear what is causing the delay; but as the government dithers, free speech suffers.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Times v. UK: another cop out

The European Court of Human Rights has just notified its judgment in the case of Times v. UK, which concerned the question of the application of the UK's libel laws to newspaper Internet archives. This case raised two important questions of principle:
  1. whether archived news items should be considered to be published afresh whenever they are read and therefore potentially open to a defamation action many years after their original publication
  2. whether online publications should be required to monitor their entire archive and append notices to old news items whenever libel proceedings are initiated with regard to them
The Court manage to wrangle out of ruling on the first point, and on the second question considered that, on the facts of the case, there was no violation. It refused to rule on the wider issue of the chilling effect of the continuing vulnerability of archived stories to libel threats but conceded that "libel proceedings brought against a newspaper after a significant lapse of time may well, in the absence of exceptional circumstances, give rise to a disproportionate interference with press freedom under Article 10."

This is another very weak Strasbourg judgment. Arguably wrong even on the facts, I take even greater exception to the Court's narrow-minded assertion that "it is not necessary for the Court to consider in detail the broader chilling effect allegedly created by the application of the Internet publication rule in the present case" (paragraph 48). Why on earth not? Surely by ruling on points of principle the Court would redeems its position as a court of authority rather than a narrow last instance adjudicator of facts, and in the process begin to rid itself of its growing backlog of more than 100,000 cases. What Europe needs - with all respect and in the fullest understanding of the poor decisions that continue to come out of some countries - is not a court of last appeal that is collapsing under its caseload, but a constitutional court that lays down the basic rules and principles. So the current decision is not just poor for media freedom in Europe, but another step on the road towards a total collapse of the Strasbourg system.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Google streetview privacy claim dismissed

As reported by the BBC:

A legal claim by a Pittsburgh couple that Google's Street View feature violated their privacy has been thrown out by a federal judge.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Pakistan may abolish blasphemy laws?

This could be of considerable interest if it goes through - might it knock the use of these laws in Afghanistan, for example, on the head?

http://www.crosswalk.com/news/religiontoday/11598236/

Pakistan to Abolish Blasphemy Laws

Dan Wooding and Sheraz Khurram Khan

ASSIST News Service


January 19, 2009

ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN (ANS) -- The Federal Minister for Minorities, Mr. Shahbaz Bhatti, has said that Pakistan’s controversial blasphemy laws 'will be abolished.'

Talking to ANS by phone the minister said he was struggling to ensure religious freedom, human dignity and social justice in Pakistani society.

“Religious minorities have been neglected, victimized and oppressed in Pakistan,” he said. “They have faced constitutional and institutionalized discrimination and inequality but our government is committed to address the long-standing issues of minorities. We are making all-out efforts to uplift and empower minorities.

Shahbaz Bhatti maintained that minorities have played a crucial role in Pakistan’s growth and nation building.

“Pakistan would not have risen on the map of the world without the crucial contribution of minorities,” he stated.

He recalled that minorities had cast their decisive vote in partition of the province of Punjab.

The Minister said he had come to parliament to advocate the case of the oppressed and the down-trodden people. He said he would never hesitate from giving any sacrifice for his people.

On Wednesday, January 14, a group of Christian lawyers from different parts of Pakistan held a meeting in Islamabad to discuss the issues being faced by religious minorities of Pakistan. The lawyers discussed minorities-related problems at length. The meeting also discussed steps taken by the Pakistan Peoples Party government for the betterment of religious minorities of Pakistan. After the meeting, they then visited the Federal Minister for Minorities, Mr. Shahbaz Bhatti, at his office.

“We, Christian lawyers, appreciate President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Syed Yousaf Raza Gilani for taking concrete steps such as the allocation of a five percent job quota for minorities, the declaration of August 11 as Minority Day, minorities representation in Senate, increase in minorities reserved seats in provincial and national assemblies, declaration of official celebration of religious festivals of minorities and review of all discriminatory laws facing minorities,” said a resolution which was passed unanimously by the lawyers.

The lawyers said they appreciated induction of Mr. Bhatti as Federal Minister for Minorities’ Affairs and put their full confidence in his leadership.

“We appreciate his long struggle to uplift and empower religious minorities. We also assure the present government that we will remain with the government through thick and thin under the leadership of Mr. Shahbaz Bhatti for the equal rights of religious minorities of Pakistan,” the resolution added.

It also said, “We extend our full support to the present democratic government which is committed to fulfill the vision of founding father Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah. We pledge to continue our efforts for supremacy of constitution, sovereignty of parliament and establishment of enlightened and moderate society which is free from every type of discrimination and inequality.”

Those who attended the meeting included Advocate Azra Shujaat, Jamshaid Rehmatullah, Aamir Jacob Randhawa, Eric Alam Sandhu, Sadqain Gardner, Rai Zafar Naveed Bhatti, Sohail Shahzad Advocate, Javed Masih, Qaisar Haroon Gill advocate, Ruth Bashir Advocate, Shazia Gulzar Advocate and Haroon Suleman Khokhar.

Copyright 2009 ASSIST News Service

Friday, January 09, 2009

Libel tourism - another case to follow

While, according to Justice Eady, it is "fashionable to rail against libel tourism" English law will not bar it - at least not in the case that 'Magic' Alex Mardas, long resident in Greece, has now brought against the International Herald Tribune (published in France) and the New York Times. One to follow...

http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2008/3135.html

Monday, January 05, 2009

ECHR defamation cases: imprisonment & enforced apologies

In the recently decided case of Mahmudov and Agazade v. Azerbaijan, the European Court of Human Rights reaffirmed that imprisonment is not a permissible sanction in defamation cases. Unfortunately, it also continued to rule it out altogether, stating that imprisonment may be permissible "where other fundamental rights have been seriously impaired, as, for example, in cases of hate speech or incitement to violence" (para. 50). Note that this does not limit imprisonment to situations of hate speech - hate speech is given as one example. While this certainly hints in the right direction, it is still not the kind of unequivocal language one might expect from a human rights court and gives government the opportunity to keep the sanction of imprisonment on the books. Not helpful...

Meanwhile, in Kazakov v. Russia, the Court offers this interesting statement: "to make someone retract his or her own opinion by acknowledging his or her own wrongness is a doubtful form of redress and does not appear to be “necessary”". Given that 'forced' apologies are a common feature of the defamation law in many European countries, this statement may have interesting ramifications for future cases.

Wednesday, December 03, 2008

South African Supreme Court of Appeal upholds constitutionality of criminal libel

In S. v. Hoho, the Supreme Court of Appeal held that the offence had not fallen into disuse and continued to serve a purpose in democratic society. Writing for the Court, Streicher ends by quoting with firm approval from the Privy Council's holding in Worme:

"Of course, some democratic societies get along without it. But that simply shows that its inclusion is not the hallmark of the criminal law of all such societies. In fact criminal libel, in one form or another, is to be found in the law of many democratic societies, such as England, Canada and Australia. It can accordingly be regarded as a justifiable part of the law of the democratic society..."

Council of Europe Convention on Access to Official Documents

The Council of Europe has adopted a Convention on Access to Official Documents. Cause to celebrate for the worldwide FoI movement, you'd think, but no. The Convention has been criticised for having been developed in secret, with little or no public access to the text in crucial final stages of development. The text of the Convention is also severely lacking, according to NGOs as well as to the Council of Europe's own Parliamentary Assembly who called for a redraft to broaden the scope of authorities covered, impose time limits on the handling of requests, and strengthen the nature of the review processes available to people whose access requests have been denied.

On the bright side, this is still the first international treaty to establish an unequivocal right to access documents held by public bodies, subject to fairly limited exceptions. Exceptions must be precisely laid down in law, be necessary in a democratic society and must be proportionate to the protection of
  1. national security, defence and international relations;
  2. public safety;
  3. the prevention, investigation and prosecution of criminal activities;
  4. disciplinary investigations;
  5. inspection, control and supervision by public authorities;
  6. privacy and other legitimate private interests;
  7. commercial and other economic interests;
  8. the economic, monetary and exchange rate policies of the state;
  9. the equality of parties in court proceedings and the effective administration of Justice;
  10. environment; or
  11. the deliberations within or between public authorities concerning the examination of a matter.
This is as strong a statement of the right to access as you'll get anywhere(although there's an unfortunate and very silly add-on exception for States with royal families who they feel a need to exempt from the right of access altogether) and the Convention is of value for that reason alone. Time will tell how it will be implemented and whether States will focus on its strengths rather its weaknesses - but the NGO community must not neglect the Convention's strong points.

Friday, November 28, 2008

Evidence against journalists obtained through bug inadmissible, judge says

In the Guardian today:

A journalist who was accused of obtaining police information illegally walked free from court today after a judge ruled that prosecution evidence against her was inadmissible.

Sally Murrer, a reporter on the Milton Keynes Citizen newspaper, had been due to face trial along with a former Thames Valley police detective sergeant, Mark Kearney, after he was accused of leaking information to her.

Kearney was the police officer at the heart of a row over the bugging of Labour MP Sadiq Khan in an unrelated case earlier this year.

Murrer and Kearney were due to face trial after Thames Valley Police secretly recorded conversations that took place between them in the former detective's car.

However, in a landmark ruling today, judge Richard Southwell said that any evidence gathered by police using the bug should be excluded under European laws that protected the rights of journalists and their sources.

Speaking after reporting restrictions were lifted, Murrer said: "This is a victory, not simply for me, but for all journalists. My legal team have been absolutely superb and they have fought for all of us.

"It's been a very long, horrible, nasty and vindictive case and we are all exhausted. We have done all emotions over the last 19 months, now it's just about survival."

The ruling resulted in a costly prosecution case, which relied on the recorded evidence, collapsing before a lengthy trial was due to begin at Kingston Crown Court.

Murrer, 49, was accused of three offences of aiding and abetting misconduct in a public office. She pleaded not guilty to the offences in March.

Kearney, 49, from Leighton Buzzard, had been charged with eight counts of wilful misconduct in a public office by making unlawful disclosures about confidential information between July 2006 and May 2007.

A third man, a private detective and former police officer Derek Webb, 53, from Hertfordshire, pleaded not guilty to five offences of aiding and abetting misconduct in a public office.

They were due to stand trial early next year but have been formally cleared today after their barristers successfully argued that the use of the listening device was a violation of European Human Rights law.

During a four day hearing at Kingston Crown Court this week, judge Southwell was told that under Article 10 of the law, journalists' rights to freedom of expression were protected from interference by the state.

Murrer's solicitor, Louis Charalambous of Simons Muirhead and Burton, said: "Sally Murrer should never have been prosecuted. The safeguards enshrined in law for the protection of journalists have been trampled upon by Thames Valley Police - both at the outset and when they chose to bug Sally's conversations under a warrant that failed to mention that she was a journalist and later when she was arrested and brought to a police station, where, following a strip search and a night in the cells, she faced a gruelling interrogation - while her home and office were searched, and all of her notebooks seized.

"Had the case against Sally gone ahead, it would have signalled a lurch towards a police state, a situation which is abhorrent in the minds of right thinking people."

It was disclosed in February that Kearney had bugged a meeting between Tooting MP Sadiq Khan and his constituent Babar Ahmad, who was being held at Woodhill Prison, Milton Keynes.

Kearney claimed he was pressurised by the Metropolitan Police to secretly record the meeting.

Even though Murrer's charges were not connected to the MP bugging row, she has previously said she believes it is the "missing piece" in the jigsaw puzzle of her case.

Murrer has said that she believes that concern on the part of the police that Kearney - who she describes as a friend - would blow the whistle on the Khan bugging may explain the investigations into both of them, launched last year.

The National Union of Journalists, which had been backing Murrer, said Thames Valley police and the Crown Prosecution Service should be made to answer for the costly failed prosecution.

Jeremy Dear, the NUJ general secretary, said: "This is a major victory, not just for Sally but for all journalists. This case was yet another example of members of the police force believing they were above the law, able to trample over well-established journalistic rights and freedoms.

"Let's be clear, this was an attempt to make a criminal out of a journalist for receiving information that the state didn't want to get out. It was a misguided prosecution that sought to punish Sally for simply doing her job.

"This judgment sends a clear message to the authorities: they must recognise the importance of free and open journalism. Hard questions must now be asked of the police and CPS as to why these costly proceedings were allowed to get so far."

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

What price privacy?

The European Court of Human Rights' latest judgment in an Article 8 vs. Article 10 case raises an interesting question: what price privacy? Local courts awarded just under €3000 for an admittedly pretty egregious attack on privacy; the European Court said 'not enough' and found a violation of the applicant's right to private life. The judgment makes interesting reading and raises several questions - not just what is the appropriate price for a breach of medical privacy, but also whether a true statement of fact can be defamatory (something which Zagrebelsky, dissenting, seems to think but which the Court omits to discus). Even more interesting is that Popovic and Tsotsoria concur in the substance of the finding, but then dissent from the damages awarded by the European Court - €6500 - on the ground that this is too high.

Monday, November 03, 2008

Dutch abolish crime of blasphemy

The Dutch cabinet has reportedly voted to abolish the crime of blasphemy. It is a bit of a double-edged sword, however, as in its place it proposes to introduce new criminal restrictions on insulting people for their religious convictions. This 'cure' may be worse than the malady; given the number of thin-skinned religionists in the Netherlands (as elsewhere) today, it's a sure bet that there will be more than a few requests for prosecution...

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Raja Petra update

Raja Petra, a Malaysian on-line magazine editor, has been charged with sedition as well as under the Internal Security Act for a piece that he wrote back in April alleging the involvement of the deputy prime minister in a murder case. He is currently detained under the ISA.A habeas corpus application asking for his release will be decided on November 7, but even if he is freed then his sedition trial is set to continue November 10. In a piece that he wrote in another online publication, Access Malaysia, he describes this as the government taking out a double insurance policy to make sure he is kept behind lock and key.

A group of media defense lawyers from the region are cooperating in his defence. Malik Imtiaz is acting for Raja Petra (see here for his blog report on the hearing of 22nd October). The IBA sent observers to his habeas corpus hearing - George Hwang, from Singapore, was one of them. H.R. Dipendra, another Malaysian lawyer, was instructed by the Media Legal Defence Initiative (the new organisation set up to support media defence litigation) and SEAPA to also attend as 'watching brief' counsel and submitted a statement international human rights standards on administrative detention.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Buying at gunpoint

There have been reports recently of military or armed police buying at gun-point all copies of a newspaper that for some reason they don't wish to see the light of day. While one reaction to that might be to print more copies and continue selling them to the police, this may not always be possible and the practice does result in the public not getting the news. It's an unusual form of censorship and there is some US case law on it - surprisingly recent in fact - but I wonder if this issue has been litigated in other countries.